Top 10 Most Expensive Shield Nickels for Your Coin Collection
If you’re a coin collector or just someone curious about old money, you’ve probably heard of the Shield Nickel. These unique five-cent pieces were the very first nickels ever made by the United States Mint, starting in 1866. While most of them aren’t too hard to find, a few rare versions are worth thousands — even tens of thousands — of dollars.
In this article, we’ll explore the top 10 most expensive Shield Nickels that collectors would love to get their hands on. These coins are rare, historical, and highly valuable. If you have one of these in your collection or come across one at a flea market or in an old coin jar, you could be holding a real treasure.
What Is a Shield Nickel?
The Shield Nickel was produced from 1866 to 1883. It gets its name from the large shield design on the front, symbolizing strength and unity after the Civil War. The back side usually has the number 5 surrounded by stars and rays or just stars, depending on the year.
This coin was made of a copper-nickel mix and was the first of its kind after silver coins were being hoarded during and after the war. Over time, the Shield Nickel went through small design changes, and these changes, along with rare minting errors, have made certain pieces extremely valuable today.
Top 10 Most Expensive Shield Nickels
Let’s dive into the list of the most valuable Shield Nickels that collectors are hunting for.
Top 10 Shield Nickels and Their Estimated Values
| Rank | Year & Type | Special Feature | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1867 With Rays | Short-lived design | $35,000+ |
| 2 | 1866 With Rays | First year of issue | $25,000+ |
| 3 | 1877 Proof Only | Extremely low mintage | $20,000+ |
| 4 | 1878 Proof Only | Limited to proof versions | $18,000+ |
| 5 | 1868 Overdate Error (8 over 7) | Rare minting mistake | $15,000+ |
| 6 | 1869 Double Die Obverse | Strong doubling seen | $12,000+ |
| 7 | 1876 | Low mintage | $10,000+ |
| 8 | 1883 | Last year of Shield Nickel | $9,000+ |
| 9 | 1871 | Tough year for collectors | $7,500+ |
| 10 | 1867 No Rays | Second type introduction | $6,000+ |
Why Are These Coins So Valuable?
There are several reasons why certain Shield Nickels can be worth so much money:
-
Low Mintage – Some years, like 1877 and 1878, were only made as proofs, meaning only a few were ever struck.
-
Minting Errors – Overdates, double dies, and design changes can make coins rare.
-
Condition – Coins in better condition (uncirculated or proof) are far more valuable.
-
Collector Demand – Coins with history and rarity attract more attention and higher prices.
Even a Shield Nickel in worn condition can be worth hundreds, but the ones listed above are the cream of the crop.
Details on the Top Coins
-
1867 With Rays: This version of the nickel included rays between the stars on the back. It was only produced for a short time due to problems during minting. Its limited number makes it extremely valuable.
-
1877 Proof Only: No regular business strike coins were made in 1877. Only proof coins were struck, which makes them incredibly rare and sought-after.
-
1868 Overdate Error: A minting error where the number 8 was stamped over a 7 in the date. These types of mistakes are loved by collectors because they’re accidental and unique.
-
1876: This year saw fewer coins minted, and most of the ones that exist today are heavily worn, so finding one in good condition is rare.
-
1883: The final year of the Shield Nickel series. Collectors often want coins from the beginning and end of a series, so this one is popular and valuable.
How to Identify a Valuable Shield Nickel
If you have some old nickels lying around or inherited a coin collection, it might be worth checking for these signs:
-
Date: Look closely at the year. Some valuable ones have unusual digits or signs of over-stamping.
-
Design Details: Does it have rays on the back? Are there signs of doubling on the numbers or letters?
-
Condition: Coins with sharp details, little wear, and clean surfaces are more valuable.
-
Minting Quality: Proof coins have a mirror-like shine and are struck with more care.
A magnifying glass or coin microscope can help you spot tiny details that might be the key to a high-value coin.
FAQs
Q1: What is the most expensive Shield Nickel ever sold?
A: The 1867 With Rays in proof condition has been known to sell for more than $35,000 depending on its condition.
Q2: What makes the 1877 Shield Nickel so rare?
A: It was only produced as a proof coin, meaning it wasn’t made for everyday use. Very few exist today.
Q3: How do I know if my Shield Nickel is a proof coin?
A: Proof coins usually have a shiny, mirror-like finish and very sharp details. They were made specifically for collectors.
Q4: Can I find a Shield Nickel in circulation today?
A: It’s extremely unlikely. Most Shield Nickels have long since disappeared from everyday use, but they might show up in old collections or estate sales.
Q5: Where can I sell a valuable Shield Nickel?
A: Reputable coin dealers, auctions, and online platforms that specialize in coins are the best places to sell. Always get a professional appraisal first.
Final Thoughts
The Shield Nickel may be an old and often forgotten piece of American history, but to collectors, it’s a window into the past — and sometimes, a chance at a big payoff. Whether you’re an experienced collector or just starting out, knowing which coins are valuable is key. The top 10 Shield Nickels we’ve listed here are rare, special, and highly desired in the coin world.
If you’re lucky enough to find one, take good care of it. And who knows — you might just be holding a five-cent piece worth thousands.